Independent musical theatre producers Bowtie Productions are taking on a new challenge this fall with their largest yet production, Stephen Schwartz‘s tricky meta-theatrical fable Pippin. The show requires a much larger cast than the company has dealt with before, a decent sized band, lots of dancing, and period costumes, to say nothing of the dramatic demands of Roger O. Hirson’s faux-historical book with its conflicting tones, dated jokes, counterintuitive message, and tenuous relationship to the fourth wall. All of this comes together in Bowtie’s ever-judicious and capable hands to create a refreshing spectacle of theatrical fun that embraces complexity without abandoning camp and proves the incredible might of the current class of indie producers in Toronto.
Director Olivia Daniels approaches the oft maligned text with fresh eyes, avoiding the urge to reinvent the wheel but excavating every ounce of meaning that can be found between the goofy jokes and memorable Fosse routines. The casting of Stratford upstart Anthony Palermo in the leading role is crucial as he keeps his feet firmly on the ground in a role that’s often played with foppish entitlement. Palermo’s Pippin is a rich, multi-layered character whose uncertain wanderings and selfish moods play as relatable complexity, allowing the unexpected ending and its bittersweet moral to land with genuine emotional impact (his excellent chemistry with lovely mezzo Krizia Natale also helps). The rest of the impeccably cast ensemble fill out some of the world’s sillier edges including a star turn from Donna Garner as grandma Berthe who gobbles up act one crowd pleaser “No Time At All” with full command of the stage and an irresistible glint in her eye.
Though it’s the title character’s story, most productions live or die on the strength of the unnamed Leading Player whose enigmatic storytelling perspective and massive vocals provide the show’s crucial Brechtian frame. The powerful KC Martinez doesn’t disappoint, opening the show with a decadent vocal on the ear worm “Magic to Do” and infusing strong personality and Halpertian judgement throughout the whole piece. Every single voice has every single note they need for Schwartz’s demanding belt-heavy score, an unheard of feat for a young company, and though dance isn’t the strongest of the triple threat for most of this cast, choreographer Meredith Shedden doesn’t shy away from the show’s Fosse history, filling the many dance breaks with stylish and atmospheric movement.
First among Bowtie’s many strengths is their taste and consideration in programming. Five years into their history, the company is leveling up to take on a new type of piece with a bigger scope and complicated production history. It’s convincing evidence that there’s not much they can’t do.
